Forum

Notifications
Clear all

Audit Sampling Adjustments: Target vs. Actual Samples

2 Posts
2 Users
0 Reactions
216 Views
(@nir1181)
Posts: 1
New Member
Topic starter
 

Hi All,

I'm looking for help with an audit sampling process that involves adjusting deficits across priorities (P1, P2, P3, P4) based on available extra cases in subsequent priorities. The goal is to ensure the sampling does not exceed the available actual cases while aligning as closely as possible to the target. Here's the logic:

  1. If there's a deficit in P1 and extra cases in P2, the deficit should be covered from the extra cases in P2's actual.
  2. If there's a deficit in P2 and extra cases in P3, the deficit should be covered from the extra cases in P3's actual.
  3. If there's a deficit in P3 and extra cases in P4, the deficit should be covered from the extra cases in P4's actual.
  4. If there's a deficit in P4, it should be covered from any extra cases in P1, P2, or P3 (in that order).

Important Notes:

  • The sampling total across all priorities must not exceed the total of the target.
  • The sampling total must not exceed the actual cases available in each priority.
  • If the actual cases are less than or equal to the target, then the actual cases should be assigned to the sampling.
  • The deficit should be adjusted top-down, meaning if there's extra in a lower priority, it should be used to cover a deficit in a higher priority.
  • Sampling cannot be negative, so if the actual cases are zero for a priority, the sampling should also be zero.

I would appreciate any solutions, formulas, or VBA approaches to handle this efficiently. Thanks in advance!

 
Posted : 11/09/2024 1:17 am
(@catalinb)
Posts: 1937
Member Admin
 

To implement an audit sampling process that adjusts deficits across priorities (P1, P2, P3, P4) while ensuring sampling aligns as closely as possible with targets and doesn’t exceed available cases, here is an approach using Excel formulas and, optionally, VBA. This will maintain the top-down adjustment process, ensuring higher priorities (e.g., P1) are prioritized for coverage first.

Approach 1: Excel Formula-Based Solution
1. Set Up Initial Data Structure
Create columns for each priority (P1, P2, P3, P4).
Have rows for Target, Actual Cases, Deficit/Surplus, and Adjusted Sampling.
2. Calculate Deficit/Surplus
Calculate the Deficit/Surplus for each priority as:
Copy code
= Actual - Target
A positive value indicates extra cases, and a negative value indicates a deficit.
3. Distribute Extra Cases to Deficits (Top-Down Adjustment)
Use IF and MIN functions to reallocate surplus cases to cover deficits, with a top-down approach.

Example Formulas for Adjusted Sampling:

P1:

excel
Copy code
= IF(Deficit_P1 < 0, MIN(Target_P1, Actual_P1 + Surplus_P2), Target_P1)
This formula limits sampling to either the target or available actual cases, covering any deficit in P1 with available surplus from P2.

P2:

excel
Copy code
= IF(Deficit_P2 < 0, MIN(Target_P2, Actual_P2 + Surplus_P3 - Adjusted_P1), Target_P2)
This formula applies any remaining surplus from P3 to P2 after addressing the needs of P1.

P3 and P4 will follow similar logic, using the available surplus from lower priorities to meet any deficits.

Approach 2: VBA Solution for Complex Allocation
If the requirements involve dynamically adjusting allocations across different priorities, VBA can automate this by looping through priorities and adjusting as needed.

VBA Code Outline
Define Variables for Target, Actual, Deficit, and Surplus.
Loop Through Priorities (P1 to P4):
Calculate deficits and check for available surplus in the next priority.
Adjust the surplus of lower priorities to cover deficits of higher priorities.
Ensure adjustments do not exceed available cases in each priority.
Here’s a VBA code outline that accomplishes this:

vba
Copy code
Sub AdjustSampling()

Dim Target(1 To 4) As Long
Dim Actual(1 To 4) As Long
Dim Adjusted(1 To 4) As Long
Dim Surplus(1 To 4) As Long
Dim Deficit(1 To 4) As Long
Dim i As Integer

' Initialize Target and Actual values (assuming data is in columns A and B)
For i = 1 To 4
Target(i) = Cells(i, 1).Value
Actual(i) = Cells(i, 2).Value
Deficit(i) = Target(i) - Actual(i)
Surplus(i) = Actual(i) - Target(i)

' Set initial adjusted sampling to target if within actual limits
If Actual(i) >= Target(i) Then
Adjusted(i) = Target(i)
Else
Adjusted(i) = Actual(i)
End If
Next i

' Adjust deficits top-down
For i = 1 To 4
If Deficit(i) > 0 Then
' Check for available surplus in lower priorities
For j = i + 1 To 4
If Surplus(j) > 0 Then
' Calculate the amount to adjust
Dim adjustAmount As Long
adjustAmount = Application.Min(Surplus(j), Deficit(i))

' Adjust values
Adjusted(i) = Adjusted(i) + adjustAmount
Adjusted(j) = Adjusted(j) - adjustAmount
Surplus(j) = Surplus(j) - adjustAmount
Deficit(i) = Deficit(i) - adjustAmount

' Exit inner loop if deficit is covered
If Deficit(i) = 0 Then Exit For
End If
Next j
End If
Next i

' Output Adjusted Sampling
For i = 1 To 4
Cells(i, 3).Value = Adjusted(i) ' Assuming Adjusted Sampling in column C
Next i

End Sub
Explanation of VBA Code
Initial Assignment: Initializes the Target, Actual, Surplus, and Deficit arrays based on input data.
Adjust Deficits Top-Down:
Loops through each priority, checking if a deficit exists.
If there’s a deficit in a higher priority, checks for surplus in subsequent priorities and reallocates as necessary.
Output Adjusted Sampling: Writes the adjusted sampling values back to the worksheet.

 
Posted : 30/10/2024 12:47 am
Share: